When is the best time to visit Cape May, NJ?

Cape May is most affordable and least crowded in the shoulder seasons, late spring (April-May) and early fall (September-October). Summer is peak for beach activity but rates are 30-60% higher. Off-season (November-March) offers the quietest stays and sometimes the most character.

How are the waterfront rentals in Cape May chosen?

Each property in Cape May is hand-picked for genuine waterfront access, not water view, not a short walk from the beach, but doors-to-water. Listings are selected from public booking platforms (Vrbo, Airbnb, Booking.com, Whimstay) for genuine waterfront access and accurate location. Rates are set by the host and visible at the booking link.

Are the properties on SleepByTheBeach available on Vrbo or Airbnb?

Yes, each property links directly to its listing on Vrbo, Airbnb, Booking.com, Whimstay, or the host's own booking system. We curate from public listings; we don't own or manage these properties. We may earn a small commission when you book through our affiliate links at no cost to you.

What makes Cape May different from other beach towns?

Curated rentals in Cape May. It has the character of a small coastal town without the density of major resort destinations. Our curation focuses on quiet, authentic stays within walking distance of the water.

Cape May

Curated rentals in Cape May

See the 4 waterfront rentals → Get the weekly letter

6620 waterfront rentals·19 shores·Every listing on the water·Updated 2026-10-25

Cape May sits at the very tip of New Jersey, a whole town of painted Victorian houses two blocks from a wide, gently sloping beach. The promenade runs the length of the oceanfront, Cape May Point and its lighthouse are a bike ride away, and the county's barrier islands stretch thirty miles north toward Ocean City. Rentals are mostly cottages and restored houses rather than towers, and the town is walkable end to end.

StateNJ

Peak seasonJune to August

Best forWaterfront stays

Featured4 rentals

The curated list · 4 rentals

Where we would stay in Cape May.

Affiliate links. About our partners.

Sleeps Shore More

Towns Wildwood Crest14 North Wildwood4 Wildwood19 Cape May4

Pages Rentals with Pool18 Oceanfront Rentals5 Beachfront Rentals15 Waterfront Rentals20 Waterfront Houses3 Waterfront Condos17 Rentals for Couples and Small Groups17 Rentals That Sleep 8 or More3 Waterfront Rentals Under $200 a Night11 Waterfront Rentals Under $300 a Night13 Waterfront Rentals Under $500 a Night19

No. 01

Private Beach! Oceanfront Wildwood Crest Retreat

Entire condo

1 bedroom sleeps 5 private pool

Wake up to Atlantic Ocean views at this Wildwood Crest 1-bedroom, 1-bath vacation rental in the only 17-acre oceanfront resort of its kind at the Jersey Shore. Located beside the award-winning ICONA Hotel in Diamond Beach, this condo features a balcony, sunrise vistas, and access to 600 feet of private beach, an on-site restaurant, and unmatched shared amenities. Spend your days building sandcastles, collecting shells, cooling off in the pool, and ending the night fireside. The space Located in 17-Acre Seapointe Village. Unobstructed Atlantic Ocean & Sunrise Views. Private 600' Beach. 1 Mi to Cape May National Wildlife Refuge Bedroom: Queen Bed, Full Bed.

Check rates on Whimstay →

No. 02

Updated Oceanside Condo - 5 Miles to Cape May!

Entire condo

1 bedroom sleeps 6 private pool

Near Diamond Beach, about 40 miles south of Atlantic City, this 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom condo is the ideal spot to escape the noise of the big city and enjoy the tranquility of the ocean! This vacation rental is in a great central location, only 2 miles from the Wildwood Boardwalk and Wildwood Crest's many beachfront water parks. You'll also find several wineries and excellent local restaurants nearby. Make sure to visit Cape May for sightseeing or take a short stroll to Wildwood Crest Beach! The space Free WiFi. Beachfront.

Check rates on Whimstay →

No. 03

Beachfront Home, 7 Mi to Cape May!

Entire home

4 bedroom sleeps 16 private pool

Beach Chairs & Towels. Dine Al Fresco w/ Ocean Views. Multiple Living Spaces Jersey Shore living is made easy at this Villas vacation rental. The 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home is steps from the beach and 7 miles from the excitement of Washington Street Mall in Cape May. Although, you may be having too much fun with the on-site amenities to explore!

Check rates on Whimstay →

No. 04

Cozy Oceanfront Condo w/ Pool & Beach Access!

Entire condo

1 bedroom sleeps 4 private pool

Dreaming of fresh ocean breezes and the sound of crashing waves? Look no further than this homey 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom condo for your next seaside escape! Ideally located in Four Winds on the Beach, this vacation rental boasts impressive ocean views, open access to a heated swimming pool, and a prime location - just steps from the shore! After days spent strolling the Wildwood Boardwalk or exploring downtown Cape May, fire up the community grills and recount the day’s memories with loved ones. The space Ocean Views. Community Perks. Elevator Access.

Check rates on Whimstay →

Compare prices

See Cape May stays on Booking.com.

Search Booking.com →

Affiliate link.

Curated luxury alternative

Prefer a boutique hotel or villa?

If a hand-picked, design-led hotel sounds better than a vacation rental, Skylark Travel Group covers the same destinations with curated boutique stays, Mr & Mrs Smith, exclusive deals, real human concierge.

Discover Skylark → See exclusive deals

Get new waterfront rentals as we add them.

Hand-picked for genuine waterfront. New finds and off-season picks, sent when there is something worth sending. No spam.

Cape May

Where we would stay in Cape May.

Private Beach! Oceanfront Wildwood Crest Retreat

Updated Oceanside Condo - 5 Miles to Cape May!

Beachfront Home, 7 Mi to Cape May!

Cozy Oceanfront Condo w/ Pool & Beach Access!

Search every stay in Cape May on Booking.com

Prefer a boutique hotel or villa?

Get new waterfront rentals as we add them.